Tender Review Guide

How to Review a Tender Pack or Bid Package: A Step-by-Step Guide for Contractors

By TenderScope · 12 min read · UK & US Estimators Subcontractors

A 300-page tender pack lands in your inbox on a Tuesday. You have five days to price it. Where do you start? Most estimators go straight to the drawings — but that's one of the most expensive mistakes in construction bidding. This guide walks you through a professional tender and bid review process, from the first document you should open to the last check before you submit your price.

🇬🇧 UK — JCT & NEC contracts 🇺🇸 US — AIA & GMP contracts
2–3
Days lost on average reviewing a large tender manually
£10k+
Average cost of a missed scope item after award
40%
Of tender disputes trace back to scope gaps missed at bid stage
⚠ Most Common Mistake

Most estimators open the drawings first. The drawings tell you what to build — but the contract conditions and specification tell you who pays for what, under what rules, and at what risk. Always read the contract first.

Step 1 — Read the Contract Conditions Before Anything Else

Before you look at a single drawing, open the contract documents. This is the single most important step in any tender or bid review, and the one most commonly skipped under time pressure.

In the UK, you're typically looking at a JCT Standard Building Contract, JCT Minor Works, NEC4 Engineering and Construction Contract, or a bespoke form with amendments. In the US, the most common forms are AIA A101/A201, a GMP contract, or an owner-drafted bespoke form.

📋 Contract Conditions Checklist
Payment terms — How many days from valuation to payment? Standard JCT is 30 days; many clients amend to 45 or 60. US AIA contracts typically run 30 days. Longer payment terms mean you're financing the client's project.
Liquidated damages / LADs — What is the weekly or daily rate? Is there a cap? On a £500k subcontract, LADs of £10,000/week with no cap is an existential risk.
Retention — What percentage, and when is it released? Standard is 5% reducing to 2.5% at practical completion, final release at end of defects period. Many clients try to hold 5% until final account.
Termination for convenience — Can the client terminate with minimal notice and no profit compensation? This is an increasingly common amendment — price accordingly.
Design responsibility — Has any design liability been transferred to you? Check carefully — this changes your insurance requirements and risk profile significantly.
CDM / OSHA obligations — UK: Has the client transferred CDM Principal Contractor duties? US: What OSHA safety plan requirements apply?
Collateral warranties — Are you required to provide warranties to third parties? What form? Non-negotiable NHS or public sector forms carry significant liability.
Insurance requirements — Minimum levels for EL, PL, PI. Does the client require professional indemnity if you accept design responsibility?
Performance bond — Is a 10% performance bond required? This has a cost — typically 1–2% of contract value — that must be included in your price.
Sub-letting restrictions — Do you need prior approval to sub-let? Is there a notice period? Does it restrict your ability to use your preferred supply chain?

"The contract is where the money is made or lost. The drawings tell you what to build. The contract tells you who carries the risk when something goes wrong."

Step 2 — Check the Submission Requirements Before You Do Anything Else

The second document to read is the Instructions to Tenderers (UK) or the Instructions to Bidders (US). This tells you exactly what you need to submit, and getting it wrong means disqualification regardless of how competitive your price is.

Missed pre-tender site visits — which are often mandatory — are a common disqualifier. Check the dates immediately. In the UK, many NHS and public sector clients require CHAS, Constructionline Gold or equivalent. In the US, check for required bid bonds, MBE/WBE certifications, and DBE goals.

📋 Submission Requirements Checklist
Return deadline and format — Date, time, and method. Electronic portal, email, or hard copy? Late submissions are almost always rejected.
Mandatory site visit — Has it passed? Is attendance recorded? Missing this is an automatic disqualifier on many public sector tenders.
Accreditations required — UK: CHAS, Constructionline, NICEIC, Gas Safe. US: Bid bond, MBE/WBE/DBE requirements, state contractor licences.
Financial standing — Audited accounts for last 2–3 years, D&B or credit report, turnover thresholds.
Method statements required — Health & safety, programme, quality plan, environmental. These take time to prepare and are often underestimated.
RFI / clarification deadline — When must questions be submitted by? Missing this means you price blind on ambiguous items.
Pricing format — Lump sum, bill of quantities, schedule of rates, or GMP? Does a BoQ need to be priced line by line?

Step 3 — Map the Documents and Identify Gaps

Before reading the specification or drawings in detail, create a simple index of every document in the pack and check it against the document schedule. Missing documents are one of the most common sources of commercial exposure — you can't price what you don't know about, but the contract often still holds you responsible for it.

What to CheckUK TermUS TermRisk if Missing
Detailed quantity scheduleBill of Quantities (BoQ)Schedule of Values / Quantity TakeoffHIGH — pricing based on assumption only
Hazardous materials surveyAsbestos survey / HSE reportHazmat / environmental surveyHIGH — programme and cost risk
Distribution board / electrical schematicE-BD drawingsElectrical one-line diagramsHIGH — cannot design or price scope
MEP coordination drawingsM&E coordinationMEP coordination drawingsMED — interface risk with other trades
Soil / ground investigationGround investigation reportGeotechnical report / soil reportHIGH — groundworks risk
Structural calculationsStructural engineer's drawingsStructural engineer drawingsMED — temporary works assumptions
Planning conditionsPlanning permission conditionsPermit conditions / zoningMED — working restrictions, materials
💡 Pro Tip

Always check the drawing schedule against the drawings actually included. It's common for 3–5 drawings to be listed but not issued — particularly for later design stages. Flag every missing drawing as a critical RFI before you price the affected scope.

Step 4 — Read the Specification Systematically

The specification is where scope is defined in words, and it's where the most expensive surprises hide. Read it systematically by trade — don't jump between sections. Mark every requirement that needs a specialist price, every standard that must be met, and every interface with other trades.

In the UK, specifications reference British Standards (BS 7671, BS 5839, BS 5266 etc.). In the US, they're organised by CSI MasterFormat divisions. Either way, the process is the same — read it line by line, flag ambiguities, and note every approved product or named manufacturer that may limit your supply chain.

1

Identify your primary scope sections

Read only the sections relevant to your trade first. Note page references for everything you need to price — don't try to read the full spec in one pass.

2

Flag named products and approved manufacturers

Named manufacturers (e.g. Gent Vigilon for fire alarms, Wandsworth for nurse call) affect your supply chain and procurement lead times. Identify them early.

3

Check performance standards and testing requirements

Commissioning, testing, certification and O&M manuals are often buried in the spec. They carry real labour cost and must be priced — not assumed to be included by others.

4

Identify interface trade responsibilities

Who provides the power to your equipment? Who patches after your first fix? Who provides builder's work drawings? Unresolved interfaces become variations — or worse, disputes.

5

Note contradictions between documents

Specification says one product, drawing shows another. Schedule says one size, spec says different. Every contradiction is an RFI and potential variation. Flag them all before pricing.

Step 5 — Review the Programme and Site Constraints

The programme (UK) or schedule (US) tells you when you're expected to work and in what sequence. It directly affects your preliminary costs, your procurement lead times, and your risk of sectional completion LADs or LDs.

Key questions to ask: Is the programme realistic for the scope? Is the building occupied during works? Are there restricted working hours — and what do they mean for your productivity rates? Are there sectional completion dates with separate LAD/LD provisions attached to each?

⚠ Watch Out For

A 26-week programme for a hospital ward refurbishment in a live clinical environment is tight. A 16-week programme for a full M&E fit-out of a 3,000m² commercial floor plate is almost certainly unachievable. If the programme is unrealistic, say so in your qualifications — and price the risk accordingly.

Step 6 — Build Your Risk Register

By this point you should have a list of everything that could go wrong commercially. Formalise it. A structured risk register does three things: it helps you price risk premiums properly, it informs your qualifications, and it protects you in disputes after award.

RiskRatingCommercial ImpactAction
Missing Bill of Quantities / no quantity scheduleHIGHPricing based on assumptions — significant exposure on quantitiesRequest BoQ or price with detailed assumptions stated
Asbestos / hazmat survey not providedHIGHUnknown programme delays and remediation costsExclude asbestos-related works; request survey
45-day payment terms (amended from standard 30)HIGHFinancing cost — price extended prelims accordinglyInclude finance cost in rate build-up
Termination for convenience — no profit compensationHIGHRisk of loss on mobilisation costs if terminated earlyQualify: exclude profit loss from termination clause
Incomplete MEP coordination drawingsMEDInterface risk — scope gaps discovered on siteInclude provisional sum; flag in qualifications
Listed building / heritage constraintsMEDApproval delays; restricted fixing methodsInclude time and cost for heritage approvals
Sub-metering not specifiedLOWAdditional cost if required but not pricedExclude; flag as assumption in qualifications

Step 7 — Prepare Your RFIs Before the Deadline

Every gap, ambiguity, and contradiction you've identified needs a formal Request for Information submitted before the RFI deadline. Well-written RFIs protect you commercially — they create a paper trail that shows you identified the problem before submission, not after award.

A good RFI has four elements: the specific reference in the documents, the exact question, the assumption you're pricing on if no answer is received, and the commercial impact of that assumption.

✓ Example RFI — Well Written

Subject: Cable schedule E-CS-001 availability

Reference: Drawing schedule, page 6 — cable schedule E-CS-001 listed as "not issued"

Question: When will cable schedule E-CS-001 be available? Should the existing £35,000 provisional sum be adjusted pending its issue?

Pricing assumption: Sub-mains cabling priced as £50,000 provisional sum pending issue of cable schedule.

Commercial impact: Without cable schedule, sub-mains installation cannot be accurately priced for a 3,200m² building with four ward distribution boards.

Step 8 — Write Your Qualifications and Exclusions

Your price submission should be accompanied by a comprehensive list of qualifications and exclusions. This is not weakness — it's commercial protection. Every experienced client and main contractor knows that a properly qualified bid is a more credible bid than a bare lump sum.

Qualifications should cover: items excluded from scope, assumptions made on quantities or design, risk items priced as provisional sums, contract terms you're not accepting as written, and any departure from the employer's requirements.

"A bare lump sum with no qualifications is not a clean bid — it's a commercial blank cheque. Qualify everything you're uncertain about."

Step 9 — Make Your Go / No-Go Decision

Not every tender is worth bidding. A go/no-go analysis should consider: the commercial attractiveness of the contract value, the programme risk given site constraints, the technical complexity relative to your capabilities, the competitiveness of the bid given how many others are invited, and the quality of the tender documents themselves.

Poorly documented tenders — missing BoQs, incomplete drawings, onerous unamended contract terms — are higher risk bids. They also tend to attract fewer credible competitors, which can work in your favour. But they require more robust qualifications and higher contingency.

FactorGreenAmberRed
Document qualityFull BoQ, complete drawingsSome information missingNo BoQ, major gaps
Contract termsStandard JCT / AIA unamendedMinor amendmentsOnerous amendments, no-profit termination
ProgrammeRealistic with floatTight but achievableUnrealistic, no float
Client relationshipKnown, repeat clientUnknown but reputableUnknown, no track record
Competitors invited2–3 known competitors4–6 companiesOpen tender, 10+

Stop reviewing tender packs manually

TenderScope analyses your full tender pack or bid package — scope by trade, risk register, RFIs, contract conditions and go/no-go verdict — in 24 hours. Reviewed by a senior estimator. First report free.

Get Your Free Analysis →

Quick Reference — Tender / Bid Review Order

✅ The Right Order to Review a Tender Pack
1. Contract conditions — payment terms, LADs/LDs, retention, termination, design liability
2. Instructions to tenderers / bidders — deadlines, mandatory requirements, submission format
3. Document index — what's included vs what's missing, flag gaps immediately
4. Specification — scope by trade, standards, named products, interface responsibilities
5. Drawings — confirm scope against spec, identify contradictions, check drawing status
6. Programme / schedule — realism check, sectional completions, working hour restrictions
7. Risk register — formalise every risk, rate HIGH/MED/LOW, assign commercial impact
8. RFIs — submit before the clarification deadline, include pricing assumptions
9. Qualifications and exclusions — document everything you're uncertain about
10. Go / No-Go decision — commit to bid, qualify and bid, or decline